Two objects X and Y are thrown upwards simultaneously with the same speed. The mass of X is greater than that of Y. the air exerts equal resistive force on the two objects, then,
(A) X will be higher than Y
(B) Y will be higher than X
(C) The two objects will reach the same height
(D) Cannot say
Answer
636.3k+ views
Hint : The objects X and Y have the same initial velocity and will also have the same velocity at maximum height which is zero. We need to investigate the acceleration of the two masses.
Formula used: In this solution we will be using the following formulae;
$ {F_{net}} = ma $ where $ m $ is the mass of an object $ {F_{net}} $ is the net force acting on the object, $ a $ is the acceleration of the object.
$ {v^2} = {u^2} + 2as $ where $ v $ is the final velocity of a body, $ u $ is the initial velocity $ a $ is the acceleration of the body and is the distance covered within that period.
Complete step by step answer:
To investigate which of these two masses will have a higher maximum height, we must know the difference between their accelerations.
Performing a Newton’s second law analysis on the two masses we have
$ {F_{net}} = ma $ where $ m $ is the mass of an object $ {F_{net}} $ is the net force acting on the object, $ a $ is the acceleration of the object.
$ \Rightarrow {F_{x,net}} = {m_x}g + f = {m_x}{a_x} $ where $ {F_{x,net}} $ is the net force on mass X, $ {m_x} $ is the mass $ g $ is the acceleration due to gravity and $ f $ is the resistive force on the mass.
Similarly,
$ {F_{y,net}} = {m_y}g + f = {m_y}{a_y} $
Hence, their accelerations are
$ {a_x} = g + \dfrac{f}{{{m_x}}} $ And
$ {a_y} = g + \dfrac{f}{{{m_y}}} $
Now since $ {m_x} > {m_y} $ then $ {a_y} > {a_x} $
Now, from the equation of motion
$ {v^2} = {u^2} + 2as $ where $ v $ is the final velocity of a body, $ u $ is the initial velocity $ a $ is the acceleration of the body and is the distance covered within that period
We know at maximum height, they both have zero velocity. Accordingly, the initial velocities are equal, hence
$ 0 = {u^2} - 2{a_x}{s_x} $ (assuming upward is positive), and
$ 0 = {u^2} - 2{a_y}{s_y} $
Hence,
$ {s_x} = \dfrac{{{u^2}}}{{2{a_x}}} $ and
$ {s_y} = \dfrac{{{u^2}}}{{2{a_y}}} $
Since, $ {a_y} > {a_x} $ then $ {s_x} > {s_y} $
Hence, X will be higher than Y.
The correct option is A.
Note:
For clarity, though it may be tempting to subtract the resistive force from the weight of the body as in $ {F_{y, net}} = {m_y}g - f = {m_x}a $ , it would be wrong. This is because both the weight of the body and the resistive force are acting downward while the object is going up.
Formula used: In this solution we will be using the following formulae;
$ {F_{net}} = ma $ where $ m $ is the mass of an object $ {F_{net}} $ is the net force acting on the object, $ a $ is the acceleration of the object.
$ {v^2} = {u^2} + 2as $ where $ v $ is the final velocity of a body, $ u $ is the initial velocity $ a $ is the acceleration of the body and is the distance covered within that period.
Complete step by step answer:
To investigate which of these two masses will have a higher maximum height, we must know the difference between their accelerations.
Performing a Newton’s second law analysis on the two masses we have
$ {F_{net}} = ma $ where $ m $ is the mass of an object $ {F_{net}} $ is the net force acting on the object, $ a $ is the acceleration of the object.
$ \Rightarrow {F_{x,net}} = {m_x}g + f = {m_x}{a_x} $ where $ {F_{x,net}} $ is the net force on mass X, $ {m_x} $ is the mass $ g $ is the acceleration due to gravity and $ f $ is the resistive force on the mass.
Similarly,
$ {F_{y,net}} = {m_y}g + f = {m_y}{a_y} $
Hence, their accelerations are
$ {a_x} = g + \dfrac{f}{{{m_x}}} $ And
$ {a_y} = g + \dfrac{f}{{{m_y}}} $
Now since $ {m_x} > {m_y} $ then $ {a_y} > {a_x} $
Now, from the equation of motion
$ {v^2} = {u^2} + 2as $ where $ v $ is the final velocity of a body, $ u $ is the initial velocity $ a $ is the acceleration of the body and is the distance covered within that period
We know at maximum height, they both have zero velocity. Accordingly, the initial velocities are equal, hence
$ 0 = {u^2} - 2{a_x}{s_x} $ (assuming upward is positive), and
$ 0 = {u^2} - 2{a_y}{s_y} $
Hence,
$ {s_x} = \dfrac{{{u^2}}}{{2{a_x}}} $ and
$ {s_y} = \dfrac{{{u^2}}}{{2{a_y}}} $
Since, $ {a_y} > {a_x} $ then $ {s_x} > {s_y} $
Hence, X will be higher than Y.
The correct option is A.
Note:
For clarity, though it may be tempting to subtract the resistive force from the weight of the body as in $ {F_{y, net}} = {m_y}g - f = {m_x}a $ , it would be wrong. This is because both the weight of the body and the resistive force are acting downward while the object is going up.
Recently Updated Pages
If x a + bt + ct2 where x is in meters and t is in class 11 physics CBSE

A car covers the first half distance between two places class 11 physics CBSE

The resultant of two vectors overrightarrow P and overrightarrow class 11 physics CBSE

Find the value of cos 135 class 11 maths CBSE

A mass M is held in place by an applied force F and class 11 physics CBSE

A solution of glucose in water is labelled as 10 dfracwv class 11 chemistry CBSE

Trending doubts
One Metric ton is equal to kg A 10000 B 1000 C 100 class 11 physics CBSE

Find the value of the expression given below sin 30circ class 11 maths CBSE

What do you mean by retardation What is its SI uni class 11 physics CBSE

Draw a diagram of nephron and explain its structur class 11 biology CBSE

10 examples of friction in our daily life

Difference between physical and chemical change class 11 chemistry CBSE

