Consider the relations \[R = \{ (x,y)\,|\,x,y{\text{ are real numbers and }}x = wy{\text{ for some rational number }}w\} \] and $S = \left\{ {\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right)\,|\,m,n,p{\text{ and }}q{\text{ are integers such that }}n,\,q\,{\text{not equal to 0 and }}qm = pn} \right\}$. Then
A. R is an equivalence relation but S is not an equivalence relation
B. Neither R nor S is an equivalence relation
C. S is an equivalence relation but R is not an equivalence relation
D. R and S both are equivalence relations
Answer
303k+ views
Hint: A relation P is said to be an equivalence relation if P is a reflexive relation, symmetric relation and a transitive relation. Check if the relations R and S are equivalence relations by checking whether they are reflexive, symmetric and transitive.
Complete step by step solution:
We know that $R = \{ (x,y)\,|\,x,y{\text{ are real numbers and }}x = wy{\text{ for some rational number }}w\} $.
$(x,x) \in R\,{\text{for }}w = 1$. Therefore, R is reflexive.
$(0,c) \in R\,{\text{for }}w = 0$ but $(c,0) \notin R\,{\text{for any }}c \ne 0$. Therefore, R is not symmetric.
Since R is not symmetric, it cannot be an equivalence relation.
We know that $S = \left\{ {\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right)\,|\,m,n,p{\text{ and }}q{\text{ are integers such that }}n,\,q\,{\text{not equal to 0 and }}qm = pn} \right\}$
\[\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{m}{n}} \right) \in S\]as $nm = mn$. Therefore, S is reflexive.
If $\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right) \in S$ then $qm = pn$. If $qm = pn$ then $np = mq$. This means that $\left( {\dfrac{p}{q},\dfrac{m}{n}} \right) \in S$. Therefore, S is symmetric.
If $\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right) \in S$ and $\left( {\dfrac{p}{q},\dfrac{k}{l}} \right) \in S$ then \[qm = pn\,\] and \[lp = kq\].
From this we can say that$\dfrac{n}{m} = \dfrac{q}{p} = \dfrac{l}{k}$. Therefore, $lm = kn$.
Since $lm = kn$,$\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{k}{l}} \right) \in S$. Therefore, S is transitive.
Since, S is reflexive, symmetric and transitive, S is an equivalence relation.
Therefore, (C) S is an equivalence relation but R is not an equivalence relation is the correct option.
Note: A relation is said to be reflexive if every element of the set is related to itself. A relation is said to be symmetric if for every a related to b, b is also related to a. A relation is said to be transitive if for every a related to b and b related to c, a is also related to c.
Complete step by step solution:
We know that $R = \{ (x,y)\,|\,x,y{\text{ are real numbers and }}x = wy{\text{ for some rational number }}w\} $.
$(x,x) \in R\,{\text{for }}w = 1$. Therefore, R is reflexive.
$(0,c) \in R\,{\text{for }}w = 0$ but $(c,0) \notin R\,{\text{for any }}c \ne 0$. Therefore, R is not symmetric.
Since R is not symmetric, it cannot be an equivalence relation.
We know that $S = \left\{ {\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right)\,|\,m,n,p{\text{ and }}q{\text{ are integers such that }}n,\,q\,{\text{not equal to 0 and }}qm = pn} \right\}$
\[\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{m}{n}} \right) \in S\]as $nm = mn$. Therefore, S is reflexive.
If $\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right) \in S$ then $qm = pn$. If $qm = pn$ then $np = mq$. This means that $\left( {\dfrac{p}{q},\dfrac{m}{n}} \right) \in S$. Therefore, S is symmetric.
If $\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{p}{q}} \right) \in S$ and $\left( {\dfrac{p}{q},\dfrac{k}{l}} \right) \in S$ then \[qm = pn\,\] and \[lp = kq\].
From this we can say that$\dfrac{n}{m} = \dfrac{q}{p} = \dfrac{l}{k}$. Therefore, $lm = kn$.
Since $lm = kn$,$\left( {\dfrac{m}{n},\dfrac{k}{l}} \right) \in S$. Therefore, S is transitive.
Since, S is reflexive, symmetric and transitive, S is an equivalence relation.
Therefore, (C) S is an equivalence relation but R is not an equivalence relation is the correct option.
Note: A relation is said to be reflexive if every element of the set is related to itself. A relation is said to be symmetric if for every a related to b, b is also related to a. A relation is said to be transitive if for every a related to b and b related to c, a is also related to c.
Recently Updated Pages
Letfx be a polynomial with positive degree satisfy-class-12-maths-JEE_Main

Evaluate the definite integral given as intlimits13left class 12 maths JEE_Main

The sum of squares of two parts of a number 100 is-class-12-maths-JEE_Main

Geometry of Complex Numbers Explained

JEE Main 2023 (February 1st Shift 2) Physics Question Paper with Answer Key

JEE Main 2023 (February 1st Shift 1) Maths Question Paper with Answer Key

Trending doubts
Electron Gain Enthalpy and Electron Affinity Explained

What Are Current and Potential Difference in Electricity?

What Are Elastic Collisions in One Dimension?

Understanding Collisions: Types and Examples for Students

Isoelectronic Species: Definition, Examples & Importance

Understanding the Angle of Deviation in a Prism

Other Pages
JEE Advanced Percentile vs Marks 2026: JEE Main Cutoff, AIR & IIT Admission Guide

JEE Advanced Weightage Chapter Wise 2026 for Physics, Chemistry, and Mathematics

Understanding Average and RMS Value in Electrical Circuits

Understanding the Centre of Mass of a Semicircular Ring

Understanding Electromagnetic Waves and Their Importance

Ideal and Non-Ideal Solutions Explained for Class 12 Chemistry

